revamping another Halloween Dessert post for the early days. We just remade these Scaredy Cat Halloween Brownie idea for dessert this week.
Back in 2011, we found this idea from Everday Food Magazine. I usually flip straight to the last pages where they have the treat of the month.
The October issue had Scaredy Cat Brownies. Remember when you could bring in homebaked treats to school? Well in 2011, my daughter’s 10th birthday treat was in question.
I was not sure my 10 year old would agree to have these brownies brownie desserts as a class treat but why not ask. She mentioned she wanted brownies but how can I just send plain ones when these looked so cute. She agreed so that also meant I did not have to wait to try them out.
Let’s see how these Scaredy Cat Halloween Brownie are made.
To make more than the 16 suggested in the recipe so instead of making the brownies from scratch I used a “Box Mix” family style that is cooked in 9×9.
- Brownie Recipe
- Red Cookie Icing
- White Cookie Icing
- Chocolate Chips
- Peppermint Patties (small)
- Candy Eyeballs
I adapted this recipe slightly as I was not sure about how the kids would take to the mint flavor if I added it to the brownie batter.
Instead of adding peppermint patties to the batter, I added about 3/4 cup of M&M’s. You can add chocolate chips too.
How to assemble the Brownie Halloween Recipes
Bake the brownies per the recipe you are using. Allow them to cool slightly.
Add the Peppermint Patties in rows on top of the brownies and they will melt onto the top.
Add the chocolate chip ears to the sides of each patty.
Once you notice the tops of the patties starting to melt slightly you can add the candy eyes.
Once the patties are cooler, you can add the mouth and fags with the cookie icing.
Other Halloween Recipes You Might Like:
How to make these pretzel monsters in minutes. Make this amazing Dip and Halloween Dip Display for your next party Halloween Decor should start at the door to welcome Trick or treaters.
How to Make Chocolate Covered Pretzels into Monster Halloween Treat
Spooky Halloween Dip Display (ROTEL Sausage Dip Recipe)
Decorate Your Door with these Fall and Halloween DIY Wreaths
How to make these pretzel monsters in minutes.
Make this amazing Dip and Halloween Dip Display for your next party
Halloween Decor should start at the door to welcome Trick or treaters.
Caitlin said the kids really enjoyed the Scaredy Cat Brownie Halloween Treats and I did not have the extra steps of making the brownies from scratch.
Pin this for when you are looking for Halloween brownie decorating ideas
- Brownie mix for 9x12 pan
- 16 miniature chocolate peppermint patties,
- Candy eyes
- chocolate chips
- icing pens, for decorating
- Bake brownie recipe per recipe/ box directions.
- Let cool on a wire rack, 25 minutes, then top with 16 peppermint patties.
- Let cool 25 minutes more, then decorate peppermint patties with candy eyes and chocolate chip ears. Refrigerate until chocolate is set, 5 minutes.
- Decorate with icing pens.
- Cut and serve
Nutrition InformationYield 16 Serving Size 1 brownie
Amount Per Serving Calories 72 Total Fat 4g Saturated Fat 2g Trans Fat 0g Unsaturated Fat 1g Cholesterol 2mg Sodium 16mg Carbohydrates 10g Net Carbohydrates 0g Fiber 0g Sugar 7g Sugar Alcohols 0g Protein 1g